Murder Before Evensong – The Reverend Richard Coles

I do like a good murder mystery and I had previously greatly enjoyed Richard Coles’ biographical books ‘Fathomless Riches’ and ‘Bringing in the Sheaves’. The first of which tells of his early life and pop career with Bronski Beat and The Communards and the start of his religious career and the second dealing with life as a parish priest after his ordination. I therefore knew he could write so was really looking forward to this, his first murder mystery, although I am rather late to the party as it was published in 2022 and there are already five more books in the series featuring Canon Clement his priest-cum-detective. I have to say I was rather disappointed however.

Firstly it is rather slow to get going, and I have to say I got rather more enjoyment from the first hundred pages, which you have to get through before the first murder, in trying to work out when the book was set rather than the story being told. I was unsure as to whether it was the late eighties or the early nineties for quite a while but almost immediately after the murder there is a referred to event which clearly pinpoints the date of the death of Anthony Bowness to the evening of 23rd April 1988. You can tell that I wasn’t really gripped by the story so far as I stopped reading to look it up at the time. This was just before The Communards split up and Coles’ pop career effectively ended, which may or may not be significant in why he set it then. Once I knew a date I could keep checking items, for instance when Daniel Clement goes to the post office to buy stamps he is offered ones marking the 300th anniversary of the Welsh Bible as current commemoratives but those had already been superseded a month earlier by ones featuring sports. I still wasn’t completely drawn in by the plot, can you tell?

I think the main problem is that Canon Clement doesn’t actually do much in the way of sleuthing, he just has a bright idea near the end of the book, whilst preaching his sermon, which reveals the murderer to him. A sort of divine inspiration which frankly isn’t very satisfying. The reader is regularly reminded that Clement has a passion for pens and stationary, with him recognising valuable examples, but whilst proverbially the pen is mightier than the sword this proves to be of no consequence to the plot, so it fails to be the MacGuffin which is implied as a recurring motif.

As I said at the beginning, I know Coles can write and it is therefore highly possible that the later books are more engaging as he learns more about the structure of such novels, it is after all a perfectly competent first attempt at the genre. Am I going to read more to find out? Probably not, and I have already parted with my copy as I can’t see me ever reading it a second time.

One thought on “Murder Before Evensong – The Reverend Richard Coles”

Leave a Reply